A glimpse of the Wicked Earl

Contributed by Patrick Maume

When historians discuss whether nineteenth-century Irish landlords were really ‘bad’, William Sydney Clements, third earl of Leitrim (1806-78, succeeded 1854, shot 2 April 1878) is a leading exhibit for the prosecution.   His management of his Leitrim and Donegal estates was authoritarian; he was disliked even by police and Dublin Castle officials, with whom he constantly quarrelled; relatives called him insane.  It is widely believed that he coerced tenants’ daughters sexually by threatening evictions; his killers are Donegal folk-heroes.

Not all aspects of this portrayal are universally accepted, but Virtues Of A Wicked Earl, Dr. Anthony Malcomson’s recent biography, is a daring attempt at rehabilitation.   Malcomson argues that Leitrim was an efficient rationaliser of an indebted and mismanaged estate, and the image of Leitrim as sexual predator was fabricated by tenant and nationalist enemies. Leitrim’s relatives’ accusations of insanity derive from a will dispute; clashes with police derived from old-fashioned belief that local administration should be controlled by landlords rather than state officials.

This interpretation is certain to be contested; the dry wit Malcomson celebrates as one of Leitrim’s attractive characteristics was described by contemporary critics as having a sadistic edge.   This post, however, offers to fill a little gap in Dr. Malcomson’s portrait.

Malcomson notes that Shane Leslie’s preface to his 1954 play Lord Mulroy’s Ghost claims Leitrim flirted with Isaac Butt’s Home Rule movement but gives no source.  John Joseph Dunne (1837-1910), a Clongowes-educated adventurer from a small Offaly Catholic gentry family, was Butt’s secretary for a time.  [For a brief life of Dunne, see The Clongownian volume V, no.3 (June 1910) p.341.]  In 1896 he published (as ‘H-R-N’) Here And There Memories, a badly-organised and anecdotal book of recollections, with interesting insights. On pp147-148 Dunne writes:

I knew Lord Leitrim well, and do not believe half the infamies attributed to him.   He certainly lived a full century too late, but had he been, say, an Irish leader a century ago, that unfortunate country’s story might have to be written in other fashion than it can be written now.

[Dunne endorses Malcomson’s point that Leitrim’s resentment of Dublin Castle and belief that landlords should control local administration resembled the views of eighteenth-century “Patriot” aristocrats.]

He offered me his agency once, which, of course, I would not accept, unless for a very handsome consideration, and not at all unless I had a free hand to change the policy which oppressed his tenantry.   My outspoken refusal drew from him some flattering words…

Dunne recalls meeting Leitrim “a summer or two before he was shot” and sharing a Great Western Railway carriage with him to Mullingar:

About a month before I had lent him two books, Dr Sigerson on land tenures and Isaac Butt’s monumental (yet, alas! now unconsidered) text-book on the Irish land question.   To Mullingar we talked of nothing else.   When we parted there he said, ‘Well, it is but fair to say that fellow Butt has changed my views, but it is too late now for me to change my hand.  For that I only wish I were young.’   I never saw him alive after.  I told Butt, who was immensely pleased.   Lord Leitrim wrote him a note.  I never saw it, but it meant ‘opening a way’, and confirmed my first view that ‘that fellow Butt’ was meant not petulantly, but kindly.   I do not know if Butt replied, but he soon let me know that the matter was off, owing to some proceedings at petty sessions against a tenant…

Was Dunne Leslie’s source?  It was certainly characteristic of the Wicked Earl to assert his will in a petty quarrel, regardless of consequences.

Patrick Maume is a researcher with the Dictionary of Irish Biography.

Tags: , , , ,

9 Responses to “A glimpse of the Wicked Earl”

  1. Conor M Says:

    Patrick, is there a DIB entry on Dunne? He seems an interesting figure.

  2. Patrick Maume Says:

    There is no entry on him, I’m afraid – I’ve suggested him for inclusion as a Missing Person.
    I think “John Dunn, a politically prominent Catholic in Queen’s County and a large landowner in the Ballinakill district” whose claim before a parliamentary committee in 1824 that the extent of popular belief in Pastorini was greatly exaggerated (James Donnelly CAPTAIN ROCK, 2009 pp120-121) was his father, but I am not sure of this.

  3. Ciaran O'Neill Says:

    Patrick, was this John Joseph Dunne also father of Mary Chavelita Dunne, whose pen-name was George Egerton?

  4. Patrick Maume Says:

    Yes – I’ve checked her DIB entry and it is pretty clear from the description of her father that it is the same man. I see from it that he was secretary of the Home Rule League rather than butt’s personal secretary, as I had thought.

  5. Patrick Maume Says:

    Well spotted, by the way. Congratulations.

  6. Ciaran O'Brien Says:

    Patrick, is there anyway that readers can suggest clarifications, updates or point out errors in the DIB? Or suggest new entries?

  7. Patrick Maume Says:

    Dear Ciaran,
    Sorry for the delay in replying to your query – i have been away from base and not accessing the Net except for e-mail.
    I don’t know if we have a reader response mechanism in place, though we do monitor blog comments. Here is an example – an Irish-born lawyer in California who is working his way through it commenting on such entries as strike his fancy.
    I will check further on this and get back to you.
    At present we are focussing on catching up on people who died since the 2002 cut-off, though we are accumulating a list of possible Missing Persons for consideration.

  8. Christoper Barboza Says:

    I am very thankful to this topic because it really gives great information .-:

  9. Murray Says:

    Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iphone
    and tested to see if it can survive a thirty foot drop, just so she can be
    a youtube sensation. My iPad is now broken and she has 83 views.
    I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: